Originally Posted by
Dan Druff
Looks like cops screwed up here, but where is the full version of the video? Why is it edited? Has a full version surfaced?
Police brutality is a real problem and shouldn't be ignored, but it is also important to look at it from the other side. It is easy to cast the cops in the role of evil bully, but in reality they have a very tough job to do, and are putting their lives on the line every day, often dealing with the worst of the worst in society. Imagine if you had to deal with that every day at work, and tell me if you could make correct decisions 100% of the time.
I get what you are saying and I hear people say this sort of thing all the time, but it's not like these guys were made into cops through a draft. They choose to do the job. They choose to put their life on the line every day and to deal with the worst in society. If they can't accept the risks and all the baggage of being a cop, then they should find a new job. The aren't doing this by force and they aren't doing it for free as a volunteer.
It especially becomes tough when dealing with a physically imposing suspect who is being uncooperative. If a 110-pound woman is refusing to cooperate, it's easier to approach the suspect gently, as (in absence of a weapon) you know she can't hurt you. However, when dealing with huge and hostile men, it becomes a different story. Look at the size of the dude in that video. Would you have felt comfortable grabbing him on your own and slapping the cuffs on him?
Cops selectively enforce laws all of the time. Perhaps they should have used better judgement and not made a big deal over something so trivial. They could have just told the guy to move along or written him some sort of citation. Do we really need to use our tax dollars to pay to put this guy in jail and use our courts for "illegally" selling cigarettes? America land of the free.
So then it becomes a matter of how much force you use to subdue hostile and uncooperative suspects, and that's where the mistakes can occur. In this case, it looks like the cops got caught up in the moment of piling on to subdue the huge black guy who wouldn't cooperate, and then didn't take him seriously when he was saying he couldn't breathe.
Mistakes are not OK when it results in lost life. Somebody else said in this thread that cops usually give it to the guys "who deserve it." The problem with that is that cops are not supposed to be judge, jury and executioner. They should use minimal force to get somebody into the back of their car. They are not supposed to judge and hand out punishment.
There is a lot to be said for cooperating with police at all times, even if you feel they're in the wrong. It is rare that the cops will beat a cooperative suspect just for the fun of it. Once you're released (or out on bail), at that point you can go after them through complaints and/or lawyers.
Not everybody has the funding to go after these people with lawyers.
That's not to say there shouldn't be punishment against cops who are abusive, overly forceful, or violate policy. There should be, and the most egregious offenses should see jail time on top of disciplinary action.
Question: If it were a white guy of the exact same size, acting the exact same way, would this have happened? I bet the answer is yes.