
Originally Posted by
Dan Druff
I remember as a 14-year-old seeing that Bob Horner, then of the woeful 1986 Braves, cracked off 4 home runs in one game.
And guess what? The Braves lost anyway -- 11-8 to the Montreal Expos.
That was the only time in MLB history that a player hit 4 HR in a game, and the team lost.
Fast forward 37 years.
I was strolling through downtown Phoenix on Saturday, and wondering how the Dbacks were doing against the Braves. Eugenio Suarez hit 4 HR in that game, and you guessed it, the Dbacks lost in extras.
If you remember Horner just abruptly vanishing after that strong 1986 season, you're correct. In 1986, he hit .273 with 27 HR and held a .803 OPS. It was his second consecutive season with 27 HR, and he had 54 HR in 1000 plate appearances in those two years combined.
He wanted a whopping $2 million in 1987 as a free agent. MLB owners were colluding at the time to hold salaries down, and refused to give it to him.
He ended up going to Japan and playing that year. Despite being offered a 3-year, $10m contract to continue playing there from 1988-90, he missed the US and returned, signing a much smaller 1-year deal with the Cardinals. He injured his shoulder, played poorly, and retired after 60 games, at the age of just 31.
Had he been born 10-15 years later, he'd have done much better financially.