I wish to thank Todd for taking the time to debate me on these issues and everyone here for listening and for sharing your comments.

I have no desire to reopen the debate, preferring to let the three hours of discussion -- coincidentally the precise length of each Lincoln-Douglas debate -- stand on its own. So, please forgive me if I don't contribute much more here.

I did wish to address questions regarding PPA's contemporaneous statements on the AP/UB scandal and share further info. First, here is Sen. D'Amato's press release from that time period: http://www.scribd.com/doc/4031226/Pr...ating-Scandals.

Statement of PPA Chairman Senator Alfonse D’Amato in Response to Online Poker Cheating Scandals

Washington, D.C. (July 22, 2008) – Former Senator Alfonse D’Amato, chairman of the Poker Players Alliance (PPA), the leading poker grassroots advocacy group with over one million members nationwide, today issued the following statement in response to recent online poker cheating scandals.

“The Poker Players Alliance (PPA) is the political and public policy voice for poker players in America. Central to our mission are advocacy efforts in Washington D.C. and around the country to protect poker players from misguided and vague laws and to establish licensed and regulated Internet poker in the U.S. To be clear, the PPA is not a regulatory body for poker players or the poker industry, nor do we seek to be. We are, however, compelled to speak out when our public policy mission is potentially undermined by actions which present Internet poker in a negative light.

“Trust is paramount in poker. Sadly, this foundation has been undercut by admissions from two well-known online poker companies, Absolute Poker and Ultimate Bet, that cheating has occurred on their poker sites. The Poker Players Alliance condemns any and all cheating in poker no matter the forum in which it is played. Because of the current legal uncertainties and the lack of federal regulation and oversight, it is especially troubling when cheating occurs in online poker. This has created an untenable atmosphere and has denied the proper means to investigate allegations, administer due process and then apply appropriate penalties for the wrongdoers. We urge these companies and their regulating authority, the Kahnawake Gaming Commission, to provide a full and transparent accounting of these breaches of the public trust to help lift the black cloud that has been placed over the industry.

“The recent cheating scandals underscore the need for U.S. licensing and regulation of online poker to help protect consumers. While even the most highly regulated industries are susceptible to fraud and abuse, regulation does provide assurances that when consumers are harmed they have recourse. Further, it is abundantly clear that regulation will also address other consumer concerns by successfully providing ways to bar access by children to gambling Web sites and providing the necessary services for problem gamblers.

“The federal government cannot continue to abdicate this basic responsibility to millions of its citizens who choose to play poker on the Internet. The attempt to enforce an outright prohibition of online poker is deeply flawed and unworkable, not to mention it invades upon the personal freedoms of law-abiding adults who wish to engage in a game of skill.

“Remaining consistent with our organization’s mission, we will continue our efforts on Capitol Hill to ensure lawmakers are well educated about the benefits of regulation to protect consumers and enable the rights of poker playing adults. These scandals will not and should not be the demise of a responsible government approach to Internet poker. Instead, this can be the pathway to understanding that regulation is the key to protecting citizens and the future of America’s card game.”
Here's a screen capture of the PPA home page at that time (the archive.com link: http://web.archive.org/web/200807290...rsalliance.org ):

Name:  ub-ap press release link.jpg
Views: 213
Size:  99.9 KB

This was stickied to the top of all of 2+2 by Mason Malmuth himself. Stickies are not saved in the system, but here's a post he made at the time (here):

Hi Everyone:

We at Two Plus Two think this is a terrific statement and applaud Senator D'Amato and the Poker Players Alliance (PPA) for issuing it at this important time. It puts the PPA and us on the same page when addressing this topic, and it will also help both of our groups to move forward on many other issues and improve the overall relationship between the PPA and Two Plus Two.

Best wishes,

Mason Malmuth
Owner and Publisher
Two Plus Two Publishing LLC
www.twoplustwo.com
Here are some articles and the 2+2 thread on this from that time:


I hope that helps address this important question. Thanks.