Originally Posted by
Dan Druff
The airline rankings you posted don't really have to do with safety -- or at least not primarily. They have to do with a variety of factors, including customer service, comfort, amenities, etc.
I admit that US-based airlines suck as far as comfort/amenities/service goes. They've gone pretty much bare-bones in that regard, in order to survive post-9/11.
However, they have done a great job with safety over the past several years, so I'll give them that.
I actually felt bad for US pilots, with how the big US airline companies were jerking them around, until last year's labor issues on American Airlines. I was caught up in that mess flying back from Boston last October. The pilots were reporting fake/exaggerated maintenance problems, and had a "perfect" routine down in order to cost the traveler the maximum amount of time and inconvenience (we're talking several hours). Really pissed me off. If you hate your employer, take action against them. Do not intentionally waste hours of commuters just so they can get pissed at the company you work for. You have no right to do that. That's extremely arrogant and selfish -- essentially saying that your labor issues are of the utmost importance and everyone else's time/schedule is meaningless.
It does look like this was pilot error, as the pilot inexplicably approached way too slowly.
However, I would still trust Asiana Airlines, and I think this was a fluke.
I will say that I would not trust third-world airlines, as third world countries are notorious for cutting corners when it comes to safety.
I don't consider Asiana Airlines to be a third-world airline, though.