After going back over the BadGuy story, I found myself stuck on one point in the story. He was dating this girl for two years and claims he was serious about her, but somehow at the moment of her deepest, most desperate depression, as she is holding a gun in her hand, he tells her he wants nothing to do with her problems and walks out of the room to make himself a drink?
This is the one piece that doesn't add up. If he loved her, why would he heartlessly turn his back on her in her greatest time of need?