Originally Posted by
JimmyG_415
What?
The World Series team is intact, except for a back up 2b.
I'll take whatever holes you are eluding to.
We have hands down the best C in the NL. top 2-3 3B,
our infield is solid and by far the best "fielding" infield.
(say what you want about Belt and Crawford, on top of their bats coming around, they are EXCELLENT fielders, both will win gold glove at some point, crawford this year.)
Excellent pitching all the way through, (except for maybe a 2 time Cy young winner)
Pagan in CF, and Hunter in RF.
So the hole is in LF?
I'm not saying SF is better than LA in every position, but I don't see holes.
Let me count the ways:
1) 2B Marco Scutaro, for as great as he was in a Giants uniform in the final 3 months of the 2012 season, is a career .276 hitter with relatively little power. He has also only stolen more than 9 bases in a season once (14). He's also going to be 38 at the end of this season, so it's not like he's a talented hitter finally reaching his peak. At best, Scutaro will be an empty batting average, but he might not even be that, instead hitting .270 with little power or speed.
2) SS Brandon Crawford is a .235 career hitter who stole 1 base and hit 4 HR in well over 435 AB last year.
3) LF Gregor Blanco is a .253 career hitter with 7 career HR in over 1100 AB. He steals bases, but that only makes him good for fantasy. His platoon mate Andres Torres is a career .241 hitter and is 35 years old.
4) 1B Brandon Belt has not lived up to potential. He is still young, but so far he is looking unimpressive.
5) Ryan Vogelsong, while pitching very well in a Giants uniform, was horrendous before that, and had a career ERA around 6.00 (!!). He also missed 5 consecutive seasons before returning in 2011. He will be 36 this season, and while you can be optimistic and believe he has made an RA-Dickey-like late career transformation into a great pitcher, he's far from a lock to be solid again this year.
6) Barry Zito has sucked since putting on a Giants uniform in 2007. He has not had a sub-4.00 ERA since that time.
7) Which Tim Lincecum will show up? The great one prior to 2012, or the 2012 version with an ERA of 5.18?
I will concede that the Giants have some true talent in Posey, Sandoval, Pence (though he had a disappointing 2012), Cain, and Bumgarner. Pagan is ok, but nothing special. The bullpen also looks pretty good.
I just don't see this as a great team. They overachieved big time in 2012. They were super-hot at the end of the season, and it carried over into the postseason.