Firstly, this is just one person, and not consensus (yet). That said...
https://twitter.com/#!/x/status/1473083590707662850
What she's actually recommending is even more strict:
1) everyone wears medical-grade surgical masks
2) everyone gets vaccinated
3) everyone tests themselves before they go out in public.
Do you agree with her stance, Dwai?
https://twitter.com/#!/x/status/1473084116711137287
Last edited by khalwat; 12-22-2021 at 10:43 AM.
So Dwai, either:
1) You agree with Dr. Leanna Wen that everyone should be vaccinated, wear facemasks, get tested before going out, and that the unvaccinated should no longer be punished due to the actions of those failing to do these things or
2) You once again didn't actually read the source you posted, which directly contradicts what you've been espousing.
Which is it?
Welp Druff, you may finally end up being right about masks being performative... at least when it comes to omicron:
Here’s how long different face masks protect you from omicron variant symptoms
A new graphic from The Wall Street Journal offers a clue as to why cloth masks might not stop the omicron variant from spreading.
The graphic — which was shared widely on social media Wednesday — shows how long it takes for someone to get infected with COVID-19 if they’re wearing a certain type of mask and speaking with someone wearing a specific type of mask (or not one at all).
The graphic includes how long it would take for people wearing nothing, cloth masks, surgical masks and N95 masks to be infected by those wearing the same type of mask.
In all, the graphic shows that wearing an N95 mask offers the greatest protection. In fact, someone would be protected for 2.5 hours if they wore N95 masks and were talking to someone without a mask at all.
However, the graphic — which uses data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention — is a clear sign that cloth masks are less effective than before.https://twitter.com/#!/x/status/1478867026542219264
This was probably also true about Delta and original COVID, but due to its lesser contagiousness, and due to the Cult of the Mask (tm) developed on the left, they didn't want to admit it.
Now they're truly worried that the caseload will overload hospitals, so suddenly the "science" is changing -- telling you to wear medical grade masks instead. This allows them to still defend mask wearing (only directing you to better ones), while at the same time being able to blame the change on Omicron.
Notice we didn't have any of these charts during the other COVID variants. Wonder why.
Here's the full article: https://www.wsj.com/articles/cloth-f...84082?mod=e2tw
This was not true about the original and delta variants, that's why in the article they are very specific in stating "no longer be sufficient" and the reason it isn't effective for this highly transmissible variant.
Please note that masking doesn't "do nothing" against omicron -- look at the chart, if both parties are masked, it doubles the safe time of contact.
The problem is, this isn't sufficient for situations where you will be in contact with people for > 30 minutes (like a school setting).
But certainly masking still is beneficial for casual contact when out and about on mass transport, in stores, etc.
Last edited by khalwat; 01-07-2022 at 05:38 AM.
I think it's too early to say what the right course of action is. I'm betting they'll continue to need to wear them until we know more for certain about the potency and long-term effects of omicron.
The reason I think they may continue to require them in schools is that it has been effective against other variants, and that means they may be effective against future variants as well.
I'm very much all for eliminating masking requirements when/how the CDC advises though!
You're demonstratively incorrect. Many studies, which I cited, showed that they did work for the original and delta variants, and this article talks about why that isn't the case for this variant.
I change my mind based on evidence, I don't change evidence based on my mind. Try the same.
Last edited by khalwat; 01-07-2022 at 05:39 AM.
The primary thing that I think Druff nailed in his most recent podcasts on COVID is that each variant has to be treated as a different thing.
COVID is not a monolithic entity that you can lump together; each variant has unique characteristics in terms of transmissibility, potency, lethality, and mode of transmission.
So he's spot-on in saying that we need to re-evaluate what we're doing to combat whatever the current strain is.
But it is intellectually disingenuous to then retroactively apply what works or doesn't work for the omicron variant to the original strain, or delta.
You need the CDC to tell you what you seem to already know? Seems to me the only reason the kids should continue to be masked in school is because the all powerful rulers of parents and children (the unions) say so. The CDC is going to tailor their recommendations based on what the teacher unions tell them to do. That is if past history is any indication
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)