Originally Posted by
Steve-O
Really, like your swedish unsolved murder rates comments? No offense, but you tend to comment on anything and everything, and I'm sure anyone with more time than me can go through your political posts and find multiple Euro references.
First of all I'm very pro gun, but to say that ramping up gun laws would be a disaster is frankly stupid, because you're basing it on nothing but your own thoughts on the matter. How would it be a disaster? has it been attempted before, either here, or in another country that had lax gun laws and tightened them up? How do you balance this with the fact that different states have vastly different gun laws, and there is no evidence that tighter restrictions are disastrous? Massachusetts is not overrun with a problem of only criminals having guns despite really strict gun laws.
Second, how can you say Europeans don't understand the US, and then go on to say you don't claim to comment on European politics because you don't know enough about them? Wouldn't this imply that you don't know what Europeans know or don't know about the US? And how does an uninformed Euro's opinion on gun laws (or social security) differ from an uninformed US resident? I would bet that the average follower of politics in Belgium knows more about US policy than an uninformed US voter who watches 30 minutes of news before Leno.
You don't need an example of something that was tried and failed to know that a bad idea would be a disaster. There is no state in the US with full gun control (that is, prohibiting gun ownership for non-law-enforcement citizens). If such gun control existed, the guns would remain in the hands of the criminals, while the law-abiding citizens would be unarmed. This would also embolden the criminals to rob more homes and businesses, knowing that people couldn't defend themselves. That's how I know it would be a disaster. I'm using common sense.
I also never comment about European politics except to say that what works there will not necessarily work here.
My point about Europeans commenting on American politics is that they don't live here, and don't fully understand the culture and the issues this country faces. You can read about it, you can watch documentaries about it, and you can watch news about it, but you don't fully understand a culture until you have lived it.
A highly educated and informed Belgian knows far less what it's like to live in America than an ignorant, uninformed doofus American. That's because one experiences America daily, while the other does not.
When Europeans read about US crime and say, "OMG OMG why don't you have gun control?" or when they hear about the health care debate and say, "OMG OMG why doesn't the government provide health care to its citizens?", they are speaking from the position of an outsider.
It's much like childless people commenting on parenting issues. I used to think I was qualified to critique all parenting issues, and while I still stand by a lot of what I previously thought, I also discovered that I had a lot to learn from actually being there as a parent.