Originally Posted by
gimmick
This is pretty pointless considering how much evidence exists that it wasn't reproduced or engineered in any way. And as i mentioned before is not something WHO is currently investigating.
The sane line for "came from a lab" is about accidents relating to sample collection, storage or study. The conspiracy about a lab/bioweapon doesn't refer to that at all.
Probably need to mention that by reproducing we're also not talking about cultivating. Letting it multiply on it's own. That's relatively easy. Building it from scratch or modifying an existing benign virus is insanely hard and will leave marks.
And as you said most of the "proof" about any of the engineering comes from a Bannon funded non-peer reviewed paper that's completely worthless when it comes to basic science/forensics.
CDC is among others an organization that stores, collects, studies, cultivates and sells viruses/bacteria. Once upon a time they sold with American Type Culture Collection prerequisites of Anthrax to Iraq. There is nothing out of the ordinary with any of that. Excluding the war crime part. Where i'm going with this is that there are labs within US that could cause a viral Chernobyl on any given day.
The problem here is that there's a lot of unknowns, and anyone asserting they "know" the origins is just blowing smoke.
This is especially true when it comes to China, a horrible government which does a lot of evil things, and which is the opposite of transparent. If a lab was involved, there's a good chance it was indeed for weapons research. Since everything is bottled up so tight there, we will probably never get the truth.
I'm not sure why you are trying to draw the distinction whether the lab created it from scratch or simply reproduced a virus they discovered in nature. For the purposes of this discussion, it's not important. The question is if we're in this mess because they were screwing around with COVID-19 in a lab, and the answer very possibly is yes.
Unfortunately, the left has politicized this, as they decided back in February 2020 that they're going to defend China as much as possible, once Trump referred to it as "the Chinese virus". It was perceived that any vilification of China in regards to COVID would validate Trump's rhetoric, so the left made it their mission to make China look as innocent as possible. Laughably, they were even pushing China's "handling" of COVID as a success story, even though the precipitous drop in cases/deaths made no sense, and clearly were a lie.
I see duped_samaritan was duped again, though.