As one would expect, Mumble's source is mostly propaganda and erroneous information.

According to Wikipedia, Reed had a history of violence against women, and was actually in jail for a separate incident when he was charged with this attack. Also, according to police there was semen inside the victim AND saliva on her chest that matched his. Also, at the time of the trial the defense did not come up with a single witness to corroborate that Reed and Stiles were in a relationship or even knew each other.

Whether you believe there should be a death penalty or whether this case deserves the penalty, or even the irregularities around the case is one thing. But lets at least try to be a little honest when describing what happened.