PFA has never led me astray for travel advice so I'd like to get tips on planning a trip to Hawaii. I recently won a trip valued at about $3500 in one of those charity lotteries. Biggest thing I've ever won in a draw. They had a default itinerary but we can change it to whatever we want and pay extra (which is what we'll do).

A few things about our trip:
-we're going in April or early May
-it's just me and Mrs. Shrink
-we'd like to venture outside a resort and explore a bit
-we plan to stay 10-12 days

A few questions:
-which islands are must-sees?
-in 10-12 days how many islands should we try to hit?
-is a car rental recommended?
-will I see Dog the Bounty Hunter?
-is Pearl Harbor worth checking out?
-should I eat poi?

Thank you, and mahalo.