Originally Posted by
Gookieheimowitz
Hut: You are not correct here . The new law only covers bets under $5,000.00 . Anything over $5,000 is subject to 28.5% withholding no matter what the bet size or combo .
This was one of the original reasons tracks went to offering .50 cent wagers on Pick 3, s and Pick4,s also the same reason why they offer .10 cent superfecta's
The last pick4, combo I had paid $10k plus . Taxes withheld . The same night pick 3 paid $1,700 Old law taxes get reported, New law no taxes . I will agree that the new tax law on Horse Racing should bring more people to the sport if they understand economically how advantageous it is now to wager on Horse racing and make a nice profit with Zero tax liability .
So new law is 600-1 x total bet , total combos, up to $5,000.00 which is still awesome
I don't know....everything I have read says what I wrote earlier.
http://www.thoroughbreddailynews.com...we-all-did-it/
Before last week, horseplayers wagering on pari-mutuel races were subject to reporting on proceeds of $600 or more and automatic federal tax withholding on pari-mutuel proceeds of more than $5,000 if the winning amount was also at least 300 times larger than the “amount of the wager.” Previously, the “amount of a wager” was defined as the winning base unit, which virtually guaranteed that a high percentage of multi-horse and multi-leg wagers triggered reporting and/or withholding for horseplayers.
For example, the IRS considered the amount wagered to be $1 in the case of a $1 Pick Six consisting of 140 different combinations costing the bettor $140. Because the 300/1 ratio is reached at just $300 when the amount of the wager in only $1, any payoff on this $140 Pick Six wager in excess of $600 triggered reporting and any payoff above $5,000 triggered automatic withholding. This was a major problem because withholding and even reporting to some extent reduced players’ liquidity during handicapping and adversely impacted pari-mutuel handle and purses.
The new regulations published last week clarify “the amount of the wager” to include the entire amount wagered into a specific pari-mutuel pool by an individual, not just the winning base unit. Back to the example above, a $1 pick 6 ticket costing $140 will not be subject to withholding or reporting unless that winning payoff exceeds $42,000 (300 x $140 = $42,000).
EDIT: Looks like you are correct. I found the actual law. Interesting though that all the commentaries I have read got it wrong.
(b) Winnings subject to withholding--(1) In general. Winnings subject to
withholding means any payment from--
(i) A wager placed in a State-conducted lottery (defined in paragraph (c)(2) of this
section) but only if the proceeds from the wager exceed $5,000;
(ii) A wager placed in a sweepstakes, wagering pool, or lottery other than a
State-conducted lottery but only if the proceeds from the wager exceed $5,000; or
(
iii) Any other wagering transaction (as defined in paragraph (c)(3) of this section)
but only if the proceeds from the wager:
(A) Exceed $5,000; and
(B) Are at least 300 times as large as the amount of the wager.
(2) Total proceeds subject to withholding. If proceeds from the wager qualify as
winnings subject to withholding, then the total proceeds from the wager, and not merely
amounts in excess of $5,000, are subject to withholding.
(
RE EDIT: Actually upon reading the law more closely I think my initial statement was correct. It says the proceeds must be greater than $5000 AND be 300X the wager. It says AND not OR. It seems unlikely that every source I have read would get this wrong. TVG announced changes and their example supports my initial position.
from TVG...
Sure! If you bet the above $2 Pick 4 ticket L1: 2,5,6,7,9 L2: 2,6,7 L3: 1,3,5,7,9 L4: 6,9 it would cost $300. If this ticket were to pay $8,000, under the old rules this would be a reportable ticket that required withholdings. It is more than $600 and 300 to 1 at a $2 ticket cost whereby $2 is the multiplier. You would receive $5,998 to your account, with $2,000 withheld. Under the new rules, the multiplier is the entire $300. Now, not only is this not a withholding ticket but it isn’t even reportable, saving you $2,000 in withholdings.