Best Quarterback in the NFL?
Curious for PFA consensus.
Andrew Luck
Aaron Rodgers
Tom Brady
Matthew Stafford
Jameis Winston
Derek Carr
Andy Dalton
Cam Newton
Drew Brees
Russell Wilson
Best Quarterback in the NFL?
Curious for PFA consensus.
Last edited by Tegnation22; 04-10-2017 at 11:13 AM.
"I hit that shot because it was a defining moment and when a defining moment comes along, you either define the moment or the moment defines you" Roy "Tin Cup" Mcevoy
Is this a trick question? obv Aaron Rodgers
Slava Ukraini!
Voted Brady of course. But you left out matti ice. Andy dalton lol.
Dam i knew I left off a few but i did this during lunch at work.Originally Posted by Tellafriend
Matt Ryan Boston College legend...I'm ashamed.
"I hit that shot because it was a defining moment and when a defining moment comes along, you either define the moment or the moment defines you" Roy "Tin Cup" Mcevoy
Rodgers, and not really close
Dam i knew I left off a few but i did this during lunch at work.
Matt Ryan Boston College legend...I'm ashamed.
Notre Dame is playing at Boston College, which has a first down with three minutes left in the half.
A Boston College fan sets off a firecracker, and Notre Dame, thinking it’s the end of the half, runs off the field.
Three plays later, Boston College punts.
I despise the Cheatriots and Brady but seriously how is this a question.. Brady has 5 fucking rings more then any QB in SB history and he's gonna be a first ballot HOF in Canton when he finally retires with possibly 1 more ring even. Patriots are to football what the Empire is to StarWars.. Bellichek is the Emperor and Brady is Darth Vader.. (one could argue Kraft is the Emperor and Bellichek is Darth Vader but then who the fuck does that make Brady?? although I am convinced Gronk is JarJar)
www.jokerstarspoker.com / www.jokerstarspoker.net / www.jokerstarspoker.eu
www.jokerstarspoker.club (not your mommas chinese poker app)
Curious how you picked these
Not much thought...sitting in lunch room surrounded by burnt out office drones and just picked 10 premier QBs.
"I hit that shot because it was a defining moment and when a defining moment comes along, you either define the moment or the moment defines you" Roy "Tin Cup" Mcevoy
Eli belongs there over of Stafford, Winston and Dalton.
If we are talking about the best in the NFL right now , Eli wouldnt break top20
Slava Ukraini!
Aaron Rodgers is definitely great, but we're talking about arguably the best QB in the history of the game with Brady. IMO it's really not even close. The guy has been winning Superbowls with sub par receivers and running backs for years. If he had the receiving core Rodgers has he would have the undefeated record most likely as well.
If we are talking about the best in the NFL right now , Eli wouldnt break top20
Your wife knows more about football than you do.
Brady had some shit casts early on, but since 2007 his offensive weapons have been better than what Rodgers has had.
Brady has the history obviously, but Rodgers is simply better at playing QB. You can find 30-50 throws a year that Rodgers makes that literally no other QB in the league could pull off.
I agree with the second part of your second statement and wholeheartedly disagree with your first...lolBrady had some shit casts early on, but since 2007 his offensive weapons have been better than what Rodgers has had.
Brady has the history obviously, but Rodgers is simply better at playing QB. You can find 30-50 throws a year that Rodgers makes that literally no other QB in the league could pull off.
Coincidental timing for this:
http://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/nfl/...BBnba9I#page=1
You also forgot Big Ben who i would draft in my top 5. He's a winner. No other way to say it.
Belichick has been a value/Moneyball guy forever. Trading 1st round draft choices for a bucket of 3's. Trading star players and sending Boston into a shitstorm on sports talk radio.Brady had some shit casts early on, but since 2007 his offensive weapons have been better than what Rodgers has had.
Brady has the history obviously, but Rodgers is simply better at playing QB. You can find 30-50 throws a year that Rodgers makes that literally no other QB in the league could pull off.
"Why doesn't he ever get star receivers to compelement Brady?"
On paper you are always feeling the Pats are over rated. There is zero doubt the complementary players have been inferior. That's where "in Bill we trust" came from. We don't get it on paper. They suck, lol. You just surrender to the better intellect in Brady & Belichick.
So what is this thread about? Best gifted athlete? Rodgers can throw the ball out of the stadium? Brady is not Aaron Rodgers. He isn't a tremendous athlete.
So decide what a quarterback is.
Brady is a Moneyball Belichick guy. Belichick was watching game film when he was 7 years old with his father in Annapolis. Was watching a 30 for 30 about Michael Vick. Maybe the most naturally gifted player to ever set foot on turf. He joked with his ex coach on film that all the game film CD's were left on the front seat of his car.
Belichick taught Brady and both have lived in the film room. They know the game better than anyone today.
So who gives a shit that Rodgers is more physically talented? Brady is 40 yrs old. With a shiny new ring. It ain't about the arm. It's the head.
Belichick and Brady are making adjustments 4 plays into the game. The others adjust at half time. They get a early read on game flow. They are just smarter. Brady has a natural gift for the strategy of football as a military general uses strategy.
Guy is smart and consistent with just enough physical skills to execute.
Brady wins and the guys with the cannon arms - well, not so much.
Last edited by Sanlmar; 04-13-2017 at 10:29 AM.
Brady 18
Rodgers 9
Brees 1
Stafford 1
Brady wins the PFA Best QB Award.
"I hit that shot because it was a defining moment and when a defining moment comes along, you either define the moment or the moment defines you" Roy "Tin Cup" Mcevoy
Mahomes
It's hilarious that we as a society think everyone can be a dr, a lawyer, an engineer. Some people are just fucking stupid. Why can't we just accept that?
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Reply With Quote