Quote:
Originally Posted by
nightmarefish
Two questions for you.
1. Do you think Kap is a top ten QB in the NFL right now?
2. In your opinion, how far would the 49ers have made it this year with Alex Smith at QB?
OK, this is a decent post and worthy of a reply.
# 1 YES,
It is the feel he brings to the game, what he does you don't see in a stat sheet.
His talent is no where near Joe, but his AURA is.
NO ONE on the 49ers thinks they are out of a game w/him at the helm.
So when his stats are good enough to be # 10, and that doesn't account for his legs or the presence??????????
Fuck yeah he is top 10. I'd say # 6.
# 2 I can't say for sure either way, it would just be my opinion anyway.
I will say it is a total different team w/Alex. Alex had a great W_L record once Harbaugh arrived and was all about ball control, (which I'm fine w/with, plenty of Elite QB's are sitting home SB time).
I will say there is no way we beat Atlanta last year being in the hole 17 or get back into the Superbowl after being down 22 w/Alex.
W/ Alex if we had a big lead, the game was over, W/Alex if we got down big it was over,
W/Kap it is not as safe a lead either way.
But I'll defer to Harbaugh, he obv saw something he didn't like w/Alex, (or he wouldn't be talking to Peyton Manning)
no one is looking back, (except people who call into sports radio, and the people that do that have the same football IQ as the trolls on here.)