Quote:
Originally Posted by
PLOL
You're thinking about the NL Champs line incorrectly. Let's assume the only time they win the NL Champ is if they also win the NL central. What are the implied odds that they win their first playoff game? 50%. But, that's not the only possibility. They can also be NL Champs without winning the NL Central. Since some percentage of the time they win the NL Championship without winning the NL Central, that implies that when they do win the NL Central, that they will win that first series less than 50% of the time (ascertaining the exact number is a little more complex, but that's not really the issue). So if you do think they win their first series game at, or close to, half the time, you should definitely bet the NL Champ line, not NL Central. Essentially you're getting an extra freeroll when they only make the wildcard (even if you think they only win twice like 20% of the time).
I agree with staying away with the WS line though.
Let's work this through, and pretend the Cards are always a 50-50 shot to win any playoff series (to make it simpler).
That would give the Cards a 1-in-8 chance to win the NL as a wildcard. That would
So basically if the Cards make the playoffs via the wildcard, your $100 will average a $112.50 win, and if they make it as the NL Central winner, you'd average a $325 win.
With the NL Central bet, you are getting an $800 win (with no further variance, but let's ignore that), and a $100 loss if they make the wildcard.
If they miss the playoffs, both bets lose, so that's a wash.
So the question comes down to how likely you think it is they'll make the wildcard versus win the Central.